Softshell or waterproof shell: which do you need?

Atlantic Outdoor · updated 16 November 2026

The short answer

A waterproof shell keeps out sustained rain with a waterproof, breathable fabric and sealed seams. A softshell is stretchy, comfortable and breathable, and sheds wind and light showers, but most softshells are water-repellent rather than waterproof. In Britain many people wear a softshell most days and keep a waterproof shell for proper rain.

What a waterproof shell does

A waterproof shell, sometimes called a hardshell, uses a waterproof, breathable fabric. Stormtech's is called H2XTREME®. Rain cannot get through it, but warmth and water vapour from your body can, so you stay drier inside than you would in a plastic mac.

The seams are sealed or taped so water cannot creep in through the stitching, and the outer fabric usually has a durable water-repellent (DWR) finish that makes rain bead up and roll off.

What a softshell does

A softshell is made from a stretchy, woven fabric, often with a soft fleece backing. It moves with you, breathes well when you are active and blocks most of the wind. A water-repellent finish sheds light showers, but in steady rain water eventually soaks through.

A few softshells add a waterproof, breathable layer for wetter days, such as Stormtech's Cascades softshell with H2XTREME®. Each product description says which kind it is.

How to choose

  • Choose a waterproof shell if you are out whatever the weather: dog walks in the rain, coastal paths, football touchlines, commuting by bike or on foot.
  • Choose a softshell for dry, cool or breezy days, active walking and everyday wear, when comfort and freedom of movement matter more than storm protection.
  • Choose both if you are outdoors a lot. A softshell does most days and the shell goes in your bag or over the top when the rain sets in.

Layering them

A softshell or fleece works well as a mid-layer under a roomy waterproof shell. If you plan to layer, check the shell's size chart with that in mind. A 3-in-1 jacket does the same job with an inner layer made to zip into the shell.

Questions and answers

Is a softshell waterproof?

Most softshells are water-repellent, not waterproof: they shed showers but let water through in steady rain. Some softshells add a waterproof, breathable layer; the product description says when they do.

Which is warmer, a softshell or a waterproof shell?

A softshell with a fleece backing usually feels warmer on its own. A waterproof shell is mainly a weather barrier, and its warmth depends on what you wear underneath.

Can I wear a softshell under a waterproof jacket?

Yes, as long as the waterproof jacket has room for it. It is a flexible way to dress for changeable British weather.

More guides